The best thing about preparing different dishes is that you get to use several ingredients that you might not have come across.

You are watching: What is the difference between consomme and broth

So often, if you are a cooking enthusiast, you may find yourself envisioning specific recipes that don’t always disappoint.

Beef consommé and beef broth are complex terms that not everyone understands in the culinary world, especially for home cooks.

Stock, broth, and consommé have often been used to refer to the same thing, which is usually not the case.


Even though they may have similarities, beef consommé and beef broth vary in flavor, taste, appearance, and preparation methods. A slight change in the ingredients and quantities alters the taste and texture of these flavorings.

You need to understand the differences between these two flavorings and the perfect ingredients needed for their preparation. The good news is after understanding them; you can easily adjust them to match your preference and taste.

That said, if you don’t know how to differentiate these two, here are some of the things to look for should you get it on your menu.

So, what is beef consommé?

Consommé is a French word used during ancient times. The term was used to refer to the processes and methods employed during the preparation of specific dishes.

After several years, consommé was used to refer to an important dish that was only eaten by people of high levels in the society.


In recent times, consommé has been used to refer to a liquid usually highly concentrated with a unique aroma. The liquid is usually purified and comes from either a stock or broth.

It is considered one of the best beef soups primarily because of the high amounts of concentration.

The appearance of the soup is usually crystal clear and involves several delicate procedures that may take longer than expected.

Therefore, purification, clarification, and the addition of richness and thickness to this soup rely mainly on other ingredients.

The purification of consommé soup is optional, and you can opt to leave it out. The soup can retain its cloudy form, provided the concentration and flavor are high.

The use of egg whites can also give your soup a translucent appearance from its cloudy form.

The broth used in making a clear consommé is often heated under medium heat, making the protein rise on the surface of the stock. The liquid beneath the surface then gets clear.

The blend of several ingredients such as vegetables and ground meat traps the protein on the surface.

Consommé translates to perfect in English. Generally, it is a liquid beef broth packed with intense flavor and very minimal impurities.

How is beef consommé made?

You should know one thing about beef consommé: the procedures involved in making it slightly complicated and delicate. However, after mastering the art of preparing this broth, it becomes pretty straightforward.

The use of egg whites makes the process even more complicated, but continuous practice and patience will turn you into a pro. The time spent making this broth is worth considering how rich and delicious it usually becomes.

The good news is the making of this broth does not have multiple methods. Instead, all the techniques used require constant ingredients such as ground beef, egg whites, vegetables, tomatoes, and other ingredients of your choice.

So, if you want to know how good you are at preparing this broth, here is a procedure on what you need to do and the ingredients required.

Ingredients needed;

Diced onionsFinely diced celery (3 ribs)Diced fresh tomatoes (3 or 4)6 cups of beef stockEgg whites (4)Salt and crushed peppercorn (both between 1 and 2 tablespoons)Minced meat


Preparing and arranging your ingredients before you begin is essential. This reduces the amount of time needed for the preparation of the soup. The first procedure is usually to separate the egg whites from the yolks, which is achieved by whisking.After that, combine the egg whites with the vegetables, peppercorns, spices, and herbs. Mix them vigorously until the mixture become foamy. Seasonings are essential as they add a distinctive flavor to the broth and shouldn’t be omitted.In a food processor, add in the tomatoes, ground beef, onions, and celery. This mixture should then be pulsed for a few minutes up until they are correctly combined.The next step will be to simmer the mixture under medium heat. It would be best if you also stirred the mixture as it simmers. The maximum heat required is 120 degrees Fahrenheit.Immediately the broth starts boiling, reduce the heat to low, and stop stirring the mixture. The simmering of the broth should last between 30 and 40 minutes.Simmering on low heat ensures that the vegetables and egg whites and the minced meat clarifies the stock. This makes the broth clear and translucent with almost zero impurities.Remove the pot from the heat source after about an hour and pour the liquid into a fine mesh. The mesh sieve should be lined using a cheesecloth, usually, two layers to trap all the solids and impurities such that they cannot get their way into the final product.The mixture formed when making this liquid can be thrown as the liquid takes all the flavor.Remove unnecessary fats from the liquid and serve it hot.

What is beef broth?

Beef broth is a liquid made from simmering meat, bones, seasonings, and different herbs for about 1 or 2 hours. Culturally, this broth is made by the use of only meat and bones. However, other ingredients have been added primarily because of additional flavor.

The preparation process of this broth is usually straightforward, as all you need to do is combine all the ingredients you require and boil.

The use of herbs and spices when making this liquid broth relies on your taste buds and preference. You can easily choose to omit these ingredients.


The vegetables used to prepare the beef broth are onions, parsley, celery, and carrots. These ingredients are essential in providing nutrients to the broth, inclusive of the bones and the meat.

If you don’t have enough time to make your beef broth, they are readily available in the stores, made using several different ingredients besides the staple vegetables. The good news is; the store-bought beef broth is easy to use.

The difference between store-bought and homemade beef broth comes primarily in the flavor. A homemade version of this broth is jam-packed with flavor and a delicious aroma.

The best will be to make this broth at home. Unlike the beef consommé, beef broth does take a shorter time to prepare, and you can easily alter the flavor to fit your taste buds. You can also buy ready-made concentrates from stores if you don’t want to prepare this broth.

How is beef broth used?

Beef broth can be used in several different ways; it all depends on what you prefer. However, the most common use for beef broth is as a base for beefy stews.

You can also use beef broth as the base for specific grain dishes, for instance, risotto and pilau. Beef broth also makes just the perfect sauces and gravies you can use to accompany your main dish.


The beef broth tastes even better when taken in its original form. If you don’t find the broth enticing in beefy stews or grain recipes, you can as well drink it while still hot. The broth is packed with minerals and nutrients essential for the growth and development of the human body.

There are endless ways to use this broth, and the only limitations lie with you.

What’s the difference between beef broth and condensed beef broth?

There is only a slight difference between these two. However, condensed beef broth usually has a thicker consistency with a pronounced flavor than the standard beef broth.

Some people prefer condensed beef broth to as concentrated beef broth because of its intense flavor. Condensed beef broth can readily be used as a substitute for the beef consommé; though the flavor might not be the same, it makes a good substitute.

The texture and consistency of condensed beef broth might vary, primarily influenced by the ingredients used to make this broth.

Are beef broth and beef stock the same?

Many people have always confused beef broth and beef stock. People think these two are the same thing which is not the case. The ingredients used for the preparation of these two liquids are slightly different.

Generally, beef stock is often prepared using only beef bones with minimal amounts of meat stuck on the bones. On the other hand, beef broth is made by boiling meat, which can either have bones or no bones.

The other difference is that there is no seasoning for the beef stock, making it a versatile soup you can use readily with other dishes. Instead, the beef broth requires a variety of seasonings to infuse extra flavor to it.

Beef broth vs. beef consommé differences

The critical difference that sets these two apart is consistency. Consommé being the highly concentrated broth, is often thicker than beef broth. This property makes it the best option when you plan on making stews and sauces.

The flavor of the two is also different. The beef flavor in beef consommé is more pronounced than beef broth, caused by the excess concentration. Beef broth does have a savory flavor but is not overly sour.

The appearance of the two soups varies from one another. Beef broth is often clear usually brownish. Beef consommé has deep dark amber color free from impurities which is the reason it might appear cloudy.

Their uses also vary during cooking. Beef broth blends well with sauces and grain dishes. Consommé can easily be used as an appetizer. It also can readily be used in the preparation of other dishes because of its versatility.

Beef consommé takes a longer time to prepare than the beef broth, which only takes a few hours to simmer, and the ingredients required for the preparation are not as many as for the beef consommé.

Between beef consommé and broth, which one is healthy?

Both these liquids are healthy for consumption, and their nutritional values are almost similar. However, homemade versions are the best and outweigh the store-bought broths. This is because you can use quality ingredients when preparing the broths.

The number of calories in both of them is usually low. It is the perfect dish if you are trying to lose weight. Simmering of the bones for long periods does lead to the release of gelatin which is essential for the growth of hair and nails.

Beef consommé tends to have high amounts of potassium, iron, and calcium than beef broth which is brought by the high levels of concentration of this liquid.

Is it possible to substitute one with the other?

Substituting these two soups one for another is not a straightforward procedure unless some adjustments are made to either of them. Beef broth usually has a mild flavor, while beef consommé is often very concentrated.

Suppose you intend on using beef consommé as a substitute for beef broth. In that case, you need to dilute it to balance its concentration levels and get a thinner consistency to replicate the texture of beef broth.

In simple terms, it’s possible to substitute beef broth with beef consommé, but it is impossible to perform the vice versa.

What makes a perfect substitute for beef consommé?

Substituting beef consommé is not an easy task because of its intense beef flavor and high concentration of flavors. However, beef consommé can quickly be served on its own, and at the same time, you can easily find it used in the preparation of other dishes.

The problems come in when you don’t have beef consommé and need something with the same flavor and concentration. The shortest way to getting the best of this will be transforming beef stock into beef consommé.

That said, the ingredients required in recreating beef consommé from beef stock are too much, leading to time wastage. Mushroom consommé is the best substitute for beef consommé primarily because of the umami flavor.

What is the shelf-life of homemade beef consommé and beef broth?

The best thing about homemade dishes and recipes is that they do not contain any additional additives, making them a healthy option. You also get to add spices and herbs of your choice to match your taste buds.

See more: Coughing And Hiccups At The Same Time, Cough & Hiccup: Causes & Reasons

You can prepare both these soups in bulk as you can readily store them for very long periods. Store them in zip lock bags and place them in the fridge. The soups can last in the fridge for about 4-6 months.